- 2013 – Martin St. Louis, Tampa Bay Lightning
- 2012 – Brian Campbell, Florida Panthers
- 2011 – Martin St. Louis, Tampa Bay Lightning
- 2010 – Martin St. Louis, Tampa Bay Lightning
- 2009 – Pavel Datsyuk, Detroit Red Wings
- 2008 – Pavel Datsyuk, Detroit Red Wings
- 2007 – Pavel Datsyuk, Detroit Red Wings
- 2006 – Pavel Datsyuk, Detroit Red Wings
- 2004 – Brad Richards, Tampa Bay Lightning
- 2003 – Aleksandr Mogilnyj, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 2002 – Ron Francis, Carolina Hurricanes
- 2001 – Joe Sakic, Colorado Avalanche
- 2000 – Pavol Demitra, St. Louis Blues
- 1999 – Wayne Gretzky, New York Rangers
- 1998 – Ron Francis, Pittsburgh Penguins
- 1997 – Paul Kariya, Mighty Ducks of Anaheim
- 1996 – Paul Kariya, Mighty Ducks of Anaheim
- 1995 – Ron Francis, Pittsburgh Penguins
- 1994 – Wayne Gretzky, Los Angeles Kings
- 1993 – Pierre Turgeon, New York Islanders
- 1992 – Wayne Gretzky, Los Angeles Kings
- 1991 – Wayne Gretzky, Los Angeles Kings
- 1990 – Brett Hull, St. Louis Blues
- 1989 – Joe Mullen, Calgary Flames
- 1988 – Mats Näslund, Montreal Canadiens
- 1987 – Joe Mullen, Calgary Flames
- 1986 – Mike Bossy, New York Islanders
- 1985 – Jari Kurri, Edmonton Oilers
- 1984 – Mike Bossy, New York Islanders
- 1983 – Mike Bossy, New York Islanders
- 1982 – Rick Middleton, Boston Bruins
- 1981 – Rick Kehoe, Pittsburgh Penguins
- 1980 – Wayne Gretzky, Edmonton Oilers
- 1979 – Bob MacMillan, Atlanta Flames
- 1978 – Butch Goring, Los Angeles Kings
- 1977 – Marcel Dionne, Los Angeles Kings
- 1976 – Jean Ratelle, New York Rangers/Boston Bruins
- 1975 – Marcel Dionne, Detroit Red Wings
- 1974 – Johnny Bucyk, Boston Bruins
- 1973 – Gilbert Perreault, Buffalo Sabres
- 1972 – Jean Ratelle, New York Rangers
- 1971 – Johnny Bucyk, Boston Bruins
- 1970 – Phil Goyette, St. Louis Blues
- 1969 – Alex Delvecchio, Detroit Red Wings
- 1968 – Stan Mikita, Chicago Blackhawks
- 1967 – Stan Mikita, Chicago Blackhawks
- 1966 – Alex Delvecchio, Detroit Red Wings
|
- 1965 – Bobby Hull, Chicago Blackhawks
- 1964 – Ken Wharram, Chicago Blackhawks
- 1963 – Dave Keon, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 1962 – Dave Keon, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 1961 – Red Kelly, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 1960 – Don McKenney, Boston Bruins
- 1959 – Alex Delvecchio, Detroit Red Wings
- 1958 – Camille Henry, New York Rangers
- 1957 – Andy Hebenton, New York Rangers
- 1956 – Earl Reibel, Detroit Red Wings
- 1955 – Sid Smith, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 1954 – Red Kelly, Detroit Red Wings
- 1953 – Red Kelly, Detroit Red Wings
- 1952 – Sid Smith, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 1951 – Red Kelly, Detroit Red Wings
- 1950 – Edgar Laprade, New York Rangers
- 1949 – Bill Quackenbush, Detroit Red Wings
- 1948 – Buddy O'Connor, New York Rangers
- 1947 – Bobby Bauer, Boston Bruins
- 1946 – Toe Blake, Montreal Canadiens
- 1945 – Bill Mosienko, Chicago Blackhawks
- 1944 – Clint Smith, Chicago Blackhawks
- 1943 – Max Bentley, Chicago Blackhawks
- 1942 – Syl Apps, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 1941 – Bobby Bauer, Boston Bruins
- 1940 – Bobby Bauer, Boston Bruins
- 1939 – Clint Smith, New York Rangers
- 1938 – Gordie Drillon, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 1937 – Marty Barry, Detroit Red Wings
- 1936 – Doc Romnes, Chicago Blackhawks
- 1935 – Frank Boucher, New York Rangers
- 1934 – Frank Boucher, New York Rangers
- 1933 – Frank Boucher, New York Rangers
- 1932 – Joe Primeau, Toronto Maple Leafs
- 1931 – Frank Boucher, New York Rangers
- 1930 – Frank Boucher, New York Rangers
- 1929 – Frank Boucher, New York Rangers
- 1928 – Frank Boucher, New York Rangers
- 1927 – Billy Burch, New York Americans
- 1926 – Frank Nighbor, Ottawa Senators
- 1925 – Frank Nighbor, Ottawa Senators
|